A reason maintenance perspective on relevant Ramsey conditionals
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper presents a Ramsey account of conditionals within the framework of an implemented reason maintenance system. The reason maintenance system is built on top of a deductive reasoning engine based on relevance logic. Thus, the account of conditionals provided is not susceptible to the fallacies of relevance. In addition, it is shown that independently motivated requirements on practical relevant reason maintenance allow us to gracefully circumvent Gärdenfors’s triviality result.
منابع مشابه
Reason Maintenance and the Ramsey Test ?
The Ramsey test provides an intuitive link between conditionals and belief revision. How easy is it to incorporate a Ramseyaccount of conditionals in a reason maintenance system? In this paper, it is shown that this is indeed possible, within a relevance-logical framework. In addition, it is shown that independently motivated requirements on reason maintenance systems allow us to gracefully cir...
متن کاملBelief ascription and the Ramsey test
In this paper, I analyse a finding by Riggs et al. (1998) that there is a close connection between people’s ability to reason with counterfactual conditionals and their capacity to attribute false beliefs to others. The result indicates that both processes may be governed by one cognitive mechanism, though false belief attribution seems to be slightly more cognitively demanding. Given that the ...
متن کاملReapproaching Ramsey: Conditionals and Iterated Belief Change in the Spirit of AGM
According to the Ramsey Test, conditionals reflect changes of beliefs: α > β is accepted in a belief state iff β is accepted in the minimal revision of it that is necessary to accommodate α. Since Gärdenfors’s seminal paper of 1986, a series of impossibility theorems (“triviality theorems”) has seemed to show that the Ramsey test is not a viable analysis of conditionals if it is combined with A...
متن کاملThe Ramsey Test and the Indexicality of Conditionals: A Proposed Resolution of Gärdenfors' Paradox
Working within the AGM approach, Peter Gärdenfors has proved that — given certain auxiliary assumptions — there are no non-trivial belief revision systems that satisfy both the Ramsey test and the Preservation condition. There are various ways of reacting to Gärdenfors' paradoxical result. Gärdenfors himself has described his result as a dilemma: we must give up either the Ramsey test or the Pr...
متن کاملOn the Ramsey Test without Triviality
We present a way of classifying the logically possible ways out of Gärdenfors’ inconsistency or triviality result on belief revision with conditionals. For one of these ways—conditionals which are not descriptive but which only have an inferential role as being given by the Ramsey test—we determine which of the assumptions in three different versions of Gärdenfors’ theorem turn out to be false....
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- Logic Journal of the IGPL
دوره 18 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2010